In a bid to address the state’s long-standing legacy of slavery and racial discrimination, the California Senate has passed a trio of reparations bills.
Reparations Revolution
One of the bills, Senate Bill 1403, led by State Senator Steven Bradford, would establish the creation of the California American Freedmen Affairs Agency.
Tracing Ancestry
This agency would help Black families trace their ancestry and see if they qualify for reparations. If this bill passes, the agency would have offices to help with genealogy research and legal matters, making sure reparations are handled well.
Returning Property
Another bill, Senate Bill 1050, deals with the issue of properties taken from people because of their race. This bill will give back these properties to their original owners or their descendants or give money if giving back the property isn’t possible.
Creating a Fund
Senate Bill 1331 aims to set up a “Fund for Reparations and Reparative Justice.” This fund would provide money for the reparations programs approved by the government, making sure there’s enough money to support these important changes.
The California Reparations Task Force
These bills come from the suggestions made by the California Reparations Task Force, a group of nine people who spent two years studying the history of racial harm in California and coming up with comprehensive plans for giving out reparations.
Listening to Experts
In total, the task force proposed 115 ideas for policies to help Black Californians who have faced harm because of historical racism.
A Leader in Change
Senator Steven Bradford, the driving force behind these bills, explained that this “is about demonstrating our state’s commitment to not only recognizing the past but also taking meaningful actions toward an equitable future.”
Inheriting Debt
Bradford said California “bears great responsibility” to atone for injustices against Black Californians. “If you can inherit generational wealth, you can inherit generational debt. Reparations is a debt that’s owed to descendants of slavery. These are not a handout or charity by any measure. It is what was promised, it’s what is owed and what is 160 years overdue.”
Driving Change
He called the creation of the California American Freedmen Affairs Agency “the first step California can take in righting these wrongs.”
Facing Opposition
Despite progress, some people are against reparations. Critics argue that the state’s budget deficit makes the promises of reparations impractical.
Criticisms and Concerns
Republican Assembly member Bill Essayli remarked, “It seems to me like they’re putting, number one, the cart before the horse. They’re setting up these agencies and frameworks to dispense reparations without actually passing any reparations.”
Practical Challenges
The Senate Appropriations Committee has also raised criticisms concerning the California American Freedmen Affairs Agency. They claim that running the new agency could cost the state about $1 million each year.
Assessing the Cost of Reparations
While the Committee didn’t say how much it would cost to put the other bills into action, they did state that investigating claims from families who say their land was stolen could cost hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Looking Beyond California
California isn’t the only state looking toward reparations. New York and Illinois have established commissions to explore reparations, but none have advanced as far as California.
Evanston’s Example
Evanston, Illinois, was the first city to offer reparations for unfair housing policies in 2021.
Decades of Debate
On a national level, there’s been talk about reparations in Congress for over 30 years – but there’s been no movement happening yet.
Apologizing and Recognizing
Alongside these reparation bills, the California Assembly recently advanced a bill to issue a formal apology for the state’s role in slavery and racial discrimination.
Governor Newsom’s Apology
This follows Governor Gavin Newsom’s apology in 2019, in which he formally apologized for how the state had mistreated and been violent towards Native Americans in the past.
Support from Communities
Advocacy groups like the Coalition for a Just and Equitable California have been pivotal in pushing these bills forward.
Laying the Groundwork
In a statement, they wrote, “Together, these bills lay the groundwork for full Reparations, including direct monetary payments, the return by the state of California of stolen wealth, and the provision of new opportunities to thrive and prosper. We’re closer to Reparations than we’ve ever been.”
Featured Image Credit: Shutterstock / Philip Yabut.
The content of this article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute or replace professional financial advice.
The images used are for illustrative purposes only and may not represent the actual people or places mentioned in the article.
