He Was Ordered to Pay $61,784 for a Thumbs-Up Emoji

In a groundbreaking case in Canada, a judge ruled that a farmer must pay C$82,000 after a thumbs-up emoji was deemed sufficient to accept contractual terms. Here’s what happened.

The Farmer

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Andrii Iemelianenko

The case revolves around Chris Achter, the owner of a farming company in Swift Current, Saskatchewan.

The Buyer

Image Credit: Shutterstock / voronaman

Kent Mickleborough, a grain buyer with South West Terminal, sent out a mass text to potential clients in March 2021, expressing interest in purchasing 86 tonnes of flax at a specified price.

The Contract

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Freedomz

Mickleborough engaged in a phone conversation with Achter and later sent him a photo of the contract via text message, accompanied by the message “please confirm flax contract.”

He Replied With an Emoji

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Lanevskyi

In response, Achter simply sent a thumbs-up emoji.

Things Took a Turn

Image Credit: Shutterstock / alexkatkov

However, when the due date for the delivery of the flax arrived, Achter failed to fulfill the contract.

To complicate matters further, the price of flax had increased since the original text exchange.

The Buyer Claimed He Accepted the Terms

Image Credit: Shutterstock / CorneliaP

This disagreement led to a legal dispute between the two parties, with Mickleborough claiming that the thumbs-up emoji implied Achter’s acceptance of the contractual terms, while Achter argued otherwise.

He Argued He Just Confirmed Receiving the Text

Image Credit: Shutterstock / tiborco

In an affidavit, Achter explained that he had used the emoji solely to acknowledge that he had received the text, not as confirmation of the contract.

He stated, “I deny that he accepted the thumbs-up emoji as a digital signature of the incomplete contract. I did not have time to review the flax contract and merely wanted to indicate that I did receive his text message.”

Things Were Taken to Court

Image Credit: Shutterstock /Gorodenkoff

Justice Timothy Keene presided over the case and recognized the complexities of interpreting emoji usage.

Even the Judge Was Perplexed

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Gorodenkoff

He noted that the court had delved into various cases from Israel, New York State, and Canadian tribunals to determine the meaning of the thumbs-up emoji.

A Decision Was Ruled

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Denis—S

Ultimately, Justice Keene concluded that in the context of this particular case, the thumbs-up emoji constituted a valid means of conveying acceptance of the contractual terms.

The Emoji Can Serve as a Signature

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Luis Molinero

Keene emphasized that while a thumbs-up emoji might be considered a non-traditional way to “sign” a document, it served the purpose of a signature in this instance.

Living in the Technological World

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Tada Images

He acknowledged that the court should not attempt to impede the progress of technology and common usage.

The judge stated, “This appears to be the new reality in Canadian society, and courts will have to be ready to meet the new challenges that may arise from the use of emojis and the like.”

Judge Hopes Things Won’t Get More Confusing

Image Credit: Shutterstock / pathdoc

However, Justice Keene clarified that this ruling should not be seen as an opportunity to introduce new interpretations or meanings to existing emojis.

He expressed confidence that the decision would not open the floodgates to an array of unforeseen interpretations.

Social Media Users Expressed Their Views

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Krakenimages.com

Several social media users shared their thoughts on the incident.

One Twitter user wrote, “As Canada follows English common law, this makes sense. Contracts can be oral as well as written, so a thumbs-up emoji would most certainly signify agreement.”

Another user joked, “Sheeet. I sent a sarcastic thumbs-up to a marriage proposal. Does this mean I’m married?”

Her Parents Told Her They Were Moving Into Her House, but She Said They Could Talk to Her Lawyer

Image Credit: Shutterstock / BUNDITINAY

A young woman riled up Redditors and landed some kudos after she told her parents she was going to put them in a home. The backstory that follows is loaded with family drama and bad assumptions. You definitely don’t want to miss out on this one! Her Parents Told Her They Were Moving Into Her House, but She Said They Could Talk to Her Lawyer

They Refused to Leave Her Yard, so She Unleashed a Maze of Tactics to Reclaim Her Precious Yard

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Spectral-Design

A woman was shocked to find the peacefulness of her own home disrupted by crazy strangers. When they refused to leave, she had to get creative. Read on to hear her full story! They Refused to Leave Her Yard, so She Unleashed a Maze of Tactics to Reclaim Her Precious Yard

Texas Woman Gets Her Legs And Hands Amputated After Suffering Septic Shock After Childbirth

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Ground Picture

In a remarkable tale of resilience and strength, Krystina Pacheco, a 29-year-old woman from Pleasanton, Texas, has captured hearts worldwide with her inspiring journey of survival and reunion with her young children. Texas Woman Gets Her Legs And Hands Amputated After Suffering Septic Shock After Childbirth

She Felt Something Tickling Her Leg in Mid-Flight, and Internet Commenters are Outraged

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Roman Samborskyi

Air travel has its fair share of discomforts, from long security lines to cramped seating. However, a recent incident aboard a plane has left a passenger astonished and frustrated. Here’s what happened. She Felt Something Tickling Her Leg in Mid-Flight, and Internet Commenters are Outraged

He Told His Mother and Sister They’d Have to Pay His Bills if His Wife Stayed Home

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Khosro

A confused and frustrated husband sparked outrage on Reddit after he told his mom and sister to pay his bills if they thought his wife should give up her job. He feels bamboozled by the whole situation. Here is his full story. He Told His Mother and Sister They’d Have to Pay His Bills if His Wife Stayed Home

The post He Was Ordered to Pay $61,784 for a Thumbs-Up Emoji first appeared on Career Step Up.

Featured Image Credit: Shutterstock / Krakenimages.com. The people shown in the images are for illustrative purposes only, not the actual people featured in the story.

Source: LadBible

+ posts